We often wonder here at the Yonder why some places make it and others don't. Everybody looks for some program or step-by-step guide, when what they really need is a good dose of Canadian — as in Canadian, Texas.
“We specialize in being audacious,” Laurie Ezzell Brown, the editor of The Canadian Record, told New York Times reporter Jere Longman. “We haven’t accepted the fate of most dusty Panhandle towns. At some point, we decided not to curl up and die.” Longman wrote about Canadian's football team — now 4-0 after years when it never won a playoff — but the story is really about a town that refused to go away. There are no programs mentioned, no grand state or federal grants, no Toyota plants or industrial parks. What Canadian seems to have are a lot of people who try things to make the town better, and who keep trying. The downtown is restored. The town has made investments in eco-tourism. It's a commodities trading center. The richest guy in town has a broom and dustpan in the back of his pickup to sweep up trash he finds around town.
“We’re 100 miles from any place you can buy underwear,” said Tresea Rankin, 50, owner of the Bucket sandwich shop, who supplies seven restaurants across the Panhandle with her celebrated sourdough bread. “You make a choice. You can be of the world or have your own. We choose to have our own.” There you have it -- the key to rural economic development.
The nation's longest-running fight by a small town against the construction of a Wal-Mart is in St. Albans, Vermont, a town about a half hour from the Canadian border. People in St. Albans have been fending off the coming of a Wal-Mart since 1993, reports Sarah Schweitzer in the Boston Globe. (Opponents pictured above.)
"The duration reflects the high stakes: Should Wal-Mart win the right to build in St. Albans, opponents fear the retailer would be poised to proliferate in rural corners of a state that has resisted its overtures," Schweitzer writes. "Vermont has the fewest Wal-Marts in the nation, with four stores, compared with 46 in Massachusetts, 27 in New Hampshire and 22 in Maine. Wal-Mart officials say the push for a greater market share in Vermont reflects the realities of modern life."
The Wal-Mart fight in St. Albans has been anything but one-sided. Unemployment is over 10 percent and people in town complain there's no place in the community to buy a pair of underwear. "The conflict has divided neighbors and families, as issues of class and values have come to dominate the debate," Schweitzer writes. "Opponents say that supporters are being materialistic in forfeiting natural resources and the downtown for inexpensive wares. Supporters decry opponents as elitist for keeping jobs and cheaper goods out of a county that could use both."
The Postal Service plans to close 413 post offices. You can see the list here. Just from a glance (and we should do a real analysis), the list of post offices scheduled to die doesn't appear to be particularly rural. Glancing at the Texas list, for example, none of the six offices are in small towns. Most of the cuts are in California, followed by Florida, Ohio and New York. Lots of states -- Montana, Mississippi, Colorado, Minnesota — aren't losing a single post office.
The list was longer, but the Postal Service spared 200 sites. The Washington Post reports that the earlier list predictably "launched a firestorm of outrage from those who live in affected neighborhoods, as well as their congressional representatives." This is all considerably less than the 1,000 post offices that the Postal Service had earlier thought might be closed.
Al Tompkins at the Poynter Institute notes that a position paper issued by the National League of Postmasters argued in favor of keeping rural post offices: "Rural post offices are the backbone of rural America and are an integral part of the social, political, and economic fabric of small towns. They are the glue that holds the nation's rural communities together. If a rural post office disappears, the town often disappears. Rural customers are not second-class citizens; they deserve access to the postal services that citizens in big cities enjoy."
The recession is giving great press to North Dakota. Business Week is the latest national publication to admire the low unemployment rates on the Great Plains amidst the jobless carnage in the rest of the country. Business Week writer Rebecca Reisner goes to Bismarck and finds a city that "has remained largely unmarred by the global financial crisis, which has wrecked the U.S. housing industry, felled hundreds of banks of all sizes, and sent the national unemployment rate to nearly 10%. Right now, Bismarck residents have scant reason to worry." (Remember, however, that the Yonder found that these low unemployment rates were helped in part by outmigration.)
Reisner notes that farm commodity prices are expected to fall. But it's energy, especially wind energy, that holds the greatest promise for new jobs. North Dakota does have optimal conditions for wind farms, and wind farms are being built, including the $250 million, 77-turbine PrairieWinds ND1 project near Minot. It will be the largest wind project owned by an electric cooperative (the Basin Electric Power Cooperative). The state also has 3 to 4 billion barrels of recoverable oil.
No wonder North Dakota has a $1 billion budget surplus. Property taxes have been lowered and because no flakey "liar loans" were given in North Dakota, the state doesn't have a foreclosure problem.
A monthly survey of bankers in the rural Midwest showed continued to show "significant economic weakness," the 18th month the Rural Mainstreet economy index has shown a troubled economy. The Rural Mainstreet index, operated by economists at Creighton University, appeared to bottom out in February of this year, but the last three months have shown declining prospects. The university economists survey bankers in more than 200 small towns in 11 Midwestern states. In this survey, the bankers were asked about upcoming crop yields. More than three out of five bankers expect crop yields to be "significantly up" from last year — but lower commodity prices will mean that farm income will be down.
Most of the bankers (83%) said the "cash for clunkers" car rebate program had had little or no impact on car sales in their communities. Hiring also remained weak. “Over the past 12 months, rural areas of the region have lost almost 5 percent of their jobs,” said Goss, the Jack A. MacAllister Chair in Regional Economics at Creighton.
Retail sales were up slightly in August over July in these more than 200 rural communities. Home sales volumes were lower this August compared to a year ago. Kurt Henstorf, president of the First National Bank in Shenandoah, Iowa, said, “Home sales seem to be improving, but our commercial sector remains steady in the doldrums.”
Ag and Trade | Cool Places | Main Street Economics
Authorized by local men, organized by local women, Henderson County's Curb Market has been selling with success since 1924. Elizabeth Engelhardt pierces through the nostalgia, naming names.
During a recession, with most prices stable, Monsanto raises the cost of its soybean seed by as much as 42%. That tells you a little about how things work in the food business.