Speak Your Piece: Doomed to Repeat It?

West Virginia’s natural gas boom should be eerily familiar in a state that has lived through more than a century of mineral extraction. For some, this second round of rural industrialization is ruining homesteads and shattering dreams.

Share This:

It was on the banks of the Ohio River that I was reunited with former residents of Tyler County, Annie and John Seay. They were staying in an RV park that had become home to over a dozen transient oil and gas workers.

I first met Annie and John at their home in Lima, West Virginia, which was situated up a hollow surrounded by the vast, rolling mountains that encapsulate West Virginia. They moved here from California with the hope of living off the land and retiring in the quiet countryside.

After spending years investing in their property and building their dream home they found themselves doing the unimaginable — packing up and leaving West Virginia. Their property had been surrounded by dozens of gas wells and the smell of gas lingered in their hollow. There was no end in sight to the natural gas development that was transforming the rural landscape into an industrial zone.

“There is no respect for rural areas and rural areas are the ones getting attacked,” says Annie. After years coping with all the development, the traffic, and the insecurity of the long term consequences associated with living next to dozens of gas wells, they decided it was time to leave. They left their home in August 2014 and moved into an RV. What they hadn’t sold at auction was packed up and placed in a storage facility until the time they found their new home.

As I walked toward their RV, a large barge of coal slowly drifted down the Ohio River. It had been a few months since the last time I saw Annie and John. The weight of what had just happened and the unknown destination ahead of them was still heavy on their minds. However, their hope remained clear — to find a new home. Ideally, somewhere this could never happen again.

In recent years West Virginia has had some of the highest rates of depopulation in the country. There are many reasons, such as the lack of employment opportunities and the mechanization and decline of the coal industry.

After the Elk River chemical spill last January, dozens of for “For Sale” signs started popping up around Charleston. And now the natural gas boom has added to hastening population drain.

On my journey throughout the state I have met dozens of residents facing the same reality as Annie and John. Their stories bring to the surface larger issues that need addressed in our country today — such as mineral rights versus individual surface rights, eminent domain versus individual and community rights.

Photo courtesy of Keely Kernan
Like many West Virginians, cattle farmer Tom Bond owns only the surface rights to his land, not the underlying minerals.
Overall these stories provoke the question – what do property rights really mean? As Lewis County resident Tom Bond states: “I would be forced to contribute the value of my property to a private enterprise. It is basically unconstitutional.” Bond is an 83-year-old cattle farmer from Lewis County and like many residents living in West Virginia he does not own the minerals under the surface of his property.

Citizens across the nation are facing these challenges as natural gas development moves into their communities. What makes West Virginia unique is that in many ways this is a repeat of history. We have seen the legacy of the boom and bust coal industry, the poisoning of our waterways, and the endless boarded up houses and empty store fronts that line the streets of towns that were once prosperous. In the southern part of the state, the counties that produced the most coal are some of the poorest counties in the United States. We have seen wealth and resources leave and know what it is like to be left behind.

As I sat on the banks of the Ohio River and watched more coal barges flowing past, I thought about the direction we are heading in yet again as a state. I have always believed in storytelling, particularly visual storytelling. I think it has the potential to connect us to people and places we might not otherwise know or understand. I hope that by sharing these stories it helps promote a very important conversation about what type of future we want to have as citizens.   

Filmmaker Keely Kernan is producing a feature film, “In the Hills and Hollows,” that follows several West Virginia residents living in the middle of the natural gas boom. The film also examines the current boom in light of West Virginia’s history of mineral extraction. For more on the film and Kernan's kickstarter campaign, visit www.hillshollowsdoc.com

 

x

News Briefs