Friday, November 20, 2009

Iraq War Deaths Concentrated in Rural America

11/06/2007
vermont funeral
Army Spc. Scott McLaughlin, 29, of Hardwick, Vermont, was killed Sept. 22, 2005 in Ramadi, Iraq. Mourners comforted each other at services for him October 1, 2005.
Photo: Associated Press

More American soldiers died in Iraq in 2007 than in any other year of the war � and rural America continues to pay a disproportionate share of the cost of the conflict there and in Afghanistan.

Yonder statisticians Robert Cushing and William O�Hare report that through October 30th an outsized share of the casualties in Iraq and Afghanistan continue to come from hometowns in rural counties. Young men and women from rural communities are disproportionately represented in the military, most likely because of higher unemployment in rural areas and lower levels of education. The military has reported that young people with few economic or educational options are more likely to enlist.

As a result, the more rural the state, the higher the rates of death in the two Middle East conflicts. The death rate for rural counties is 51 percent higher than for urban ones.

Nineteen percent of the country�s people live in rural America, but these places account for 26 percent of the casualties.

O�Hare and Cushing divided the number of casualties from rural and urban areas by the total military-age population (people 18 to 59 years old) to derive a �death rate� for each state, and for urban and rural portions of each state. Eight out of the ten states with the highest overall death rate had more casualties who hailed from rural counties than urban ones.

The ten states with the lowest death rates all had more urban casualties than rural ones.

The states with the highest death rates are little changed from when the Yonder last checked in May. Vermont, North Dakota, Nebraska, Montana, South Dakota, Wyoming, Alaska, Maine, Idaho and Arkansas have the highest death rates. (All but North Dakota, Wyoming and Arkansas had more rural residents than urban killed in the conflicts.) In May, Delaware was in this group and Arkansas wasn�t.

Below is a listing of all the states and their death rates. The states are ranked from the highest death rate (Vermont) to the lowest (New Jersey). The death rate is the number of casualties per million residents between the ages of 18 and 59. Rural is defined as all counties outside metropolitan statistical areas, as defined by the federal government.






Total











Outside Metropolitan Areas (Rural)
















Inside Metropolitan Areas (Urban)











  Number of Deaths






Death Rate











Number of Deaths






Death Rate











Number of Deaths






Death Rate






Vermont






19






47.3






  16






60.6






  3






21.9






North Dakota






18






44.9






  8






39.5






  10






50.4






Nebraska






46






42.4






  27






57.1






  19






31.1






Montana






24






41.0






  22






48.7






  2






15.0






South Dakota






19






40.2






  15






51.2






  4






22.3






Wyoming






13






39.9






  5






21.9






  8






81.7






Alaska






16






36.7






  11






43.4






  5






27.4






Maine






29






34.8






  15






30.4






  14






41.3






Idaho






30






34.5






  19






34.2






  11






35.0






Arkansas






57






34.0






  28






32.8






  29






35.2






Oregon






75






33.0






  35






55.7






  40






24.3






Oklahoma






68






31.1






  23






28.1






  45






32.9






Louisiana






84






29.7






  20






29.7






  64






29.7






New Mexico






35






29.6






  13






27.1






  22






31.3






Nevada






42






28.9






  8






49.2






  34






26.3






Mississippi






52






28.9






  37






31.1






  15






24.6






Delaware






15






28.8






  6






60.4






  9






21.4






Arizona






97






28.0






  20






45.1






  77






25.5






New Hampshire






23






27.6






  11






35.4






  12






22.9






Iowa






50






27.3






  30






31.5






  20






22.8






Kansas






46






27.0






  26






37.7






  20






19.7






Texas






382






27.0






  56






29.2






  326






26.6






West Virginia






30






26.7






  17






26.2






  13






27.3






Indiana






101






26.1






  31






30.1






  70






24.7






Kentucky






67






25.6






  35






26.4






  32






24.7






Alabama






71






25.2






  24






26.9






  47






24.4






Pennsylvania






191






25.1






  45






38.6






  146






22.7






Ohio






178






25.0






  36






26.9






  142






24.5






Wisconsin






86






24.7






  38






35.1






  48






20.0






Virginia






117






24.4






  21






21.4






  96






25.2






Hawaii






19






24.3






  4






17.8






  15






26.9






Michigan






151






23.9






  41






37.1






  110






21.1






Tennessee






89






23.8






  38






32.5






  51






19.9






Missouri






81






22.6






  38






34.2






  43






17.4






South Carolina






58






22.0






  17






22.7






  41






21.8






Maryland






76






21.5






  11






44.0






  65






19.8






Georgia






124






21.5






  46






28.0






  78






18.9






Washington






86






21.4






  16






25.1






  70






20.7






Colorado






62






20.7






  19






34.7






  43






17.5






California






455






20.1






  24






32.4






  431






19.7






North Carolina






106






19.7






  33






20.2






  73






19.5






Massachusetts






80






19.7






  0






0.0






  80






20.0






Illinois






150






18.8






  42






37.4






  108






15.8






Florida






190






18.5






  15






21.3






  175






18.3






Utah






27






17.9






  4






11.3






  23






19.9






Minnesota






57






17.5






  22






24.5






  35






14.9






DC






6






16.3






  0






na






  6






16.3






New York






185






15.3






  28






28.7






  157






14.1






Rhode Island






10






14.7






  2






37.9






  8






12.8






Connecticut






31






14.2






  4






20.8






  27






13.6






New Jersey






73






13.6






  NA






NA






  73






13.6






Total






4,197






22.8






  1,102






31.4






  3,095






20.8